Why did you hafta go and fool after
We had got along just fine
But surprise, surprise
Surprise, surprise
Fate is never strange to me
I knew you was tellin' lies
Knew you was tellin' lies
I could see it in your eyes
I knew you was tellin' lies
Knew you was tellin' lies
I could see it in your eyes
I hope you're proud of all your chasin' 'round
Thinkin' I was alone all night
But surprise, surprise
Surprise, surprise
You're only foolin' yourself
'Cause I knew you was tellin' lies
Knew you was tellin' lies
I could see it in your eyes
Why did you hafta go and fool around
After we got along so fine
I knew you was tellin' lies
We got along so fine
But I knew you was tellin' lies
Knew you was talkin' jive
I could see it in your eyes